What Our Guests Say
Over 1,500 reviews — and counting. See why Sarasota loves Eleni’s.
Featured Reviews
★★★★★
“Best pizza in the Sarasota-Bradenton area hands down. The Greek-style pan pizza is incredible — thick, crispy crust with the perfect amount of cheese. Huge portions, great prices.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“We order catering trays from Eleni’s for every office meeting. The lasagna tray feeds our whole team and the price can’t be beat. Always fresh, always on time.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“This place is a hidden gem! We’ve been coming here for years and the quality never drops. The gyro platter and Greek salad are outstanding. Staff is always friendly.”
Yelp Review
★★★★★
“Ordered delivery through DoorDash and was impressed. Pizza arrived hot, the spaghetti with meatballs was homemade quality. Will definitely be ordering again.”
DoorDash Review
★★★★★
“Lunch specials are the best deal around. Two slices and a drink for under $10 — and these are BIG slices. Perfect for a quick work lunch.”
Google Review
★★★★☆
“Great family restaurant with old-school charm. The stuffed peppers reminded me of my grandmother’s cooking. Portions are very generous for the price.”
Facebook Review
Find Us On
🌏
1,200+ reviews
📜
Yelp
200+ reviews
👥
100+ reviews
Enjoyed Your Visit? Leave Us a Review!
Your feedback helps us improve and helps your neighbors discover great food. It takes less than a minute.
Review on Google Order Again